Valentine’s Day was a great experience. Scalini Fedeli Menu It is an icon with title They park cars on site and are very quick and conscientious with our car. portioned just right....Part of the menu is set, you select appetizer, main and dessert. 165 Duane Street New York, NYUse SpotHero to find parking near Scalini Fedeli. Dessert is...so good! Continuing to provide an outstanding dining experience from start to finish. Download our menus: NEW 2020 SCALINI FEDELI TRIBECA MENU . Unique experience in a traditional setting. Waitress was not attentive at all. I am sorry to see that the wine list has changed with an emphasis now on only a few area’s. Rave reviews for risottos, scallops (both carpaccio and seared), braised short ribs and pasta with "fruits de mar". In these crazy times, this was a memory of those good days gone, I’ve not been here since before the pandemic felt wonderful to be back so many familiar faces and the restaurant was better than ever!! This is the real deal, food , service and atmosphere. in a lemon and Sicilian olive dressing, pear-ricotta crostini, over pickled red onions topped with ligurian olive tapenade and provencal vegetables, grilled "Caesar" and roasted "Caprese" both dressed in an anchovy-hazelnut vinaigrette, with mushrooms and roasted sunchokes topped with fried zucchini, with prosciutto, artichokes and tropea onions finished with mint and ricotta, with Maryland crabmeat in a spicy Italian parsley, leek, and prosecco broth $8 supp, with Italian sausage and wild mushrooms in a light tomato and basil sauce, with mushrooms, black olives and minced Spanish anchovy in a spicy tomato sauce, with a sage brown butter topped with amaretti and buffalo mozzarella, with escarole, sausage, cherry pepper and anchovy with caramelized pecorino romano, in an arugula and sundried tomato sauce topped with grated goat cheese, with pancetta, onions and pepperoncini in a light tomato and basil sauce finished with mascarpone, with ricotta and spinach covered with truffle butter, with pancetta, onion and pecorino romano topped with an emulsified porcini and black truffle sauce $8 supp, in a prosecco and black truffle sauce with crispy leeks, over escarole in a light caper, parsley and garlic sauce with ricotta gnocchi, crusted Arctic char over crab meat and spinach in a roasted garlic, thyme and mushroom jus, in a spicy wine and caper jus with (verdure di campagna), in a lemon-saffron sauce with fennel puree, with Italian sausage in a rosemary and garlic sauce served over broccoli di rapa and orrichiette pasta, with a cherry pepper and port wine glaze, fennel-apple puree, chop with crispy shallots and sage in a white wine and veal jus $20 supp, crusted with almonds in a madeira and sherry vinegar sauce over a shallot and pear puree, over orange scented carrots in a balsamic and garlic flavored lamb sauce $10 supp, made with ricotta cheese and served with four sauces $4.50 supp, with orange-honey sauce and caramelized fiorelle pear over hazelnut meringues, in a baked fillo crust, served with brown sugar crumble and cinnamon gelato, topped with sweet hazelnut praline over pistachio sauce and espresso zabaglione, with cappuccino gelato and caramelized orange peel $4 supp, with chocolate mousse, fresh cream and warm raspberries with vanilla ice cream, Our selection of cheeses served with mustard fruit and toasted Tuscan bread $5 supp. Clearly the special pastas are the stars here. I’ve dined here many times and plan to return many more. The sauces for both dishes were just great. The inviting decor features vaulted ceilings and European antiques and provides the perfect setting for chef Michael Cetrulo's delightful cuisine which offers the finest ingredients coupled with a confidence and grace that ensures your meal will be a memorable one. I hated the pre fix menu. Rewarded with the highest overall ratings in the Zagat Survey, Scalini Fedeli has been granted one star by the Michelin guide in it's inaugural 2006 issue. There’s still an air of romance in the pretty room, with vaulted ceilings, tapered candles, plenty of antiques, and a preponderance of couples. Grounded in Italian roots but highlighted by distinctive French influences, Scalini Fedeli manages to set Cetrulo’s culinary vision against the backdrop of an inviting and elegantly designed dining room." Is there anywhere to park nearby other than the valet parking? Scalini Fedeli ranked among New York's finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to new heights. Sometime every year one of our friends will suggest a dinner at Scalini. I don't know if I am getting used to it or I am NOT really so impressed by...this place anymore. If you are a resident of another country or region, please select the appropriate version of Tripadvisor for your country or region in the drop-down menu. served an amuse bouche, an appetizer, a main, a sorbet intermezzo, dessert then a sweets tray to accompany your coffee or after dinner beverage. Save room for dessert! Maybe it’s time to re-read “ Setting the Table”.More, It is really a fantastic restaurant, with great Italian food! Can a gluten free person get a good meal at this restaurant? Food portion size was adequate would be better if you were able to choose your own accompaniments. The place is walking distance from our house, which is great. Can a vegan person get a good meal at this restaurant? Everyone thought the food was terrific. Food was outstanding. Not really, but one can bring in their own wine. Rewarded with the highest overall ratings in the Zagat Survey, Scalini Fedeli has been granted one star by the Michelin guide in it's inaugural 2006 issue. The Menu has great options for everyone, and the portion are quite filling. The restaurant has been open since 1995 and is located in a historical building constructed in 1740. We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. Thankfully, this is no fabrication, but Scalini Fedeli. See reviews, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for Scalini Fedeli locations in Chatham, NJ. Another wonderful evening at Scalini. The meal is a 4 course price fixed experience. Cetrulo specializes in many-course tasting meals long on finesse. this level. Scalini Fedeli is known for being an outstanding Italian restaurant. Everything was outstanding. Housed in an old farm house, the ambience and service are old school which fits the prix fixe menu (you are...served an amuse bouche, an appetizer, a main, a sorbet intermezzo, dessert then a sweets tray to accompany your coffee or after dinner beverage. Being served a glass a wine , a gin and tonic and special cocktail all in the same glassware should not happen. Went for our anniversary. The interior features high ceilings, antique pine floors and a sense of style which evokes a distinctly Tuscan feel. Scalini Fedeli is reputedly the best Italian in NJ. Be prepared to make week-end reservations well in advance. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. To date, Scalini Fedeli is my favorite Italian restaurant here in the city. Everything was fine, the only “complaint” I have is that it was a little too quiet. Five course price fixed dinner!! The service is … Sad that they are sticking to their rigid prix fix ordering as I would be back soon if I could order a la carte and get what I wanted. I'm def going back soon!! Part of the menu is set, you select appetizer, main and dessert. I had the braised pork and it was excellent. Great restaurant with a friendly staff , in these days as so many Itaian restaurants doing casual Italian we loved to see this place with elegance and style, food and service were exceptional, I’ve eaten at the restaurant several times an every time I’ve eaten there I always had a great experience the food was great the service the drinks nothing to complain about. Never genuinely excited to go, we always come away incredibly impressed. Scalini Fedeli Restaurant Review: Chef-proprietor Michael Cetrulo came to New York after creating Scalini Fedeli, a notable New Jersey Italian restaurant. Chef Michael Cetrulo’s Italian food is accomplished, if not particularly concerned with trends; service is formal. We will definitely be back. Restaurants are struggling due to Covid. Good service is black and white but hospitality turns the experience into color. All in all a great evening with the family. OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services. He stepped easily into the clean, elegant and vaulted surroundings of his home with its wood-framed windows and flower boxes. nothing else to say. Good service is black and white but hospitality turns the experience into color. Scalini Fedeli ranked among New York's finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to new heights. I enjoyed linguini with sweet peas and carbonara, Potato Encrusted Red Snapper and ended with Banana Tart with Vanilla Ice Cream. Outstanding Food and Service in Comfortable Atomosphere. I have read other reviews and they were spot on when the talked about the extra dishes from the chef (his specialties). I dined there last night and guess what? Modern & eclectic Italian with a distinct French influence, Scalini NYC is quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine. Rewarded with the highest overall ratings in the Zagat Survey, Scalini Fedeli has been granted one star by the Michelin guide in it's inaugural 2006 issue. Impeccable service and great old school Italian food. Whether you have something to celebrate or just need something to take the edge off, the drink menu at this restaurant won't disappoint. I suppose there must be but we always use complimentary valet. I would not recommend this restaurant. Will may be back but NOT anytime soon.More, We had never been here before and had a gift certificate. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment. {"baseUrl":"http://www.opentable.com","environment":"prod-sc","hostName":"mesos-agent240-prod-sc.otsql.opentable.com:31027","language":"en","releaseName":"start-page-docker_teamcity_2.0.10432","requestId":"c1410a3f-8b3a-494b-b7f1-6692e0abf4c1"}. The second courses consisted of various meat and fish, none of which I was excited to order. Food is fantastic! The outdoor setting was lovely, quiet, and with just the right amount of lighting. It's always a pleasure going to Scalini Fedeli knowing that it's never going to disappoint. I am vegetarian so paying $67 for pasta is totally ridiculous. Grimes, a writer I’ve always admired, continued with a flare that I’d be unlikely to match (though he was operating with the distinct advantage of having… Moving away from the area made it more arduous to travel there then to walk a couple blocks to their sister restaurant. Are you sure you want to delete this question? COVID update: Scalini Fedeli has updated their hours, takeout & delivery options. Roasted beet and fennel over an olive oil and goat cheese (crema), Chive and Prosecco Poached Maryland Crabmeat Napoleon, Orecchiette in a Spicy Garlic and Olive Oil Sauce, Chicken Liver and Pancetta Ravioli in a Boscaiola Sauce, Pappardelle in a Spicy Veal Shank and Pancetta "Bolognese", Diver Sea Scallops Over a Celery Root Puree, Lightly Pounded Parmigiano Crusted Rib Pork Chop, "Insalata Di Cavalo", Butternut Agnolotti with Sage - Emilia Romagna, Ricotta Gnocchi with Tomato and Arugula - Campagna, Truffle Crusted Arctic Char - Friuli - Venezia, Panino of Crisp Pistachio and Hazelnut Caramel Wafers, Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant. Being served a glass a wine , a gin and tonic and special cocktail all in the same glassware should not happen. Unless that happens, I’m not going back. Old but well maintained house, and it is truly beautiful! To book a spot: select your times and any apply any filters, find the spot that works for you, and book online for easy parking in NYC. The food was fantastic and the service prompt and professional. Superb food and service. Rated excellent by the New York Times in 1996 and New Jersey's favorite restaurant in Zagat's Survey in 2001 and New Jersey Monthly's best Italian and top 25 overall in 2007. Restaurants, Italian Tribeca Scalini Fedeli. Less than half the tables were filled on a Sunday so it was a little too quiet. The worse experience ever!!!!! Scalini Fedeli is rated 4.8 stars by 2597 OpenTable diners. So glad they are back , the food is excellent and service is professional without being overbearing, very special place !!! Scalini Fedeli. The food was terrific, excellent service, and wonderful evening!! The service is the best you can find in New York City and the food a step above of most two star Michelin restaurants. BOOK PARKING. But those were both in the “course 1” part of the meal so I chose a salad. All in all a great evening with the family.More, This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. this place anymore. The 350-bottle wine list encompasses all regions of Italy but also does justice to the best American wineries. From the minute you walk into the 260 -year-old farmhouse, you feel the elegance and warmth brought on by the beautiful vaulted ceilings and Tuscan like decor. look forward to becoming a regular once again, My favorite high end Italian in NYC. Scalini Fedeli was opened by chef-owner Michael Cetrulo in 1995 and very quickly became New Jersey's highest rated Italian restaurant. We look forward to seeing regular menu as well. Sad that they are sticking to their rigid prix fix ordering as I would be back soon if I could order a la carte and get what I wanted. Scalini Fedeli - Chatham, NJ 63 Main Street Chatham, NJ 07928 Nice and friendly! Wonderful food, wonderful service! It will be hard to beat the quality of the food. Please sign in to record your input. I have not been to Scalini Fedeli in 5 years. In comparison to other Italian restaurants, Scalini Fedeli has an expensive price point. Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Great date spot. Get the raviolo! Tripadvisor gives a Travelers’ Choice award to accommodations, attractions and restaurants that consistently earn great reviews from travelers and are ranked within the top 10% of properties on Tripadvisor. From the level of service the the quality and quantity of food, this place is a solid home run. Suggest bumping the lovely music up a notch to compensate for that. I had the braised pork and it was excellent. Let’s support them by booking a table where safe, or ordering food to go. You can close your eyes and order from their menu and you will be pleased with any and all dishes. The taste and presentation of each dish exceeds any expectation i have. I had the Tagliatelle and red Snapper. You can close your eyes and order from their menu and you will be pleased with any and all dishes. The pork shank wasn’t great and I wasn’t eager to try any of my tablemates second courses either. I should call it waddling distance, we were very full by the end of our meal. It is even better!! The food was absolutely delicious. There are many exceptional dessert choices especially if you love chocolate! I had to literally ask for menu, bread and wine list. “Scalini Fedeli means steps of faith, and in this case, it’s a leap,” William Grimes declared upon the opening of this Tribeca temple of French-influenced fine-Italian dining, in 1999. What has changed is the service that does match their top level cuisine. TriBeCa, or the Triangle Below Canal Street, became a popular neighborhood for artists and others seeking relief from the rising prices in SoHo in the late 1980s. Both the young and the young-at-heart … pasta and a salad for my meal. Service was very good. Overall, a great romantic experience. To top it off I was allowed to bring in a bottle of red white!! Come in and experience our unmatched service and food. Ideal in every measure, it would seem a figment of one’s imagination — black truffle Arctic char, parmigiano crusted pork chop, warm caramelized apple tart in a baked fillo crust. No corking few during the week. Don’t miss this restaurant if you are in the area!More, The last time we dined at Scalini was over 15 years ago. The sauces for both dishes were just great. For conscientious eaters, Scalini Fedeli has plenty of fresh and healthy items on the menu. more. Unless that happens, I’m not going back.More, The food at Scalini Fideli still matches the same quality as it was to me the first time I came here many years ago. A classic! Find 3 listings related to Scalini Fedeli in Chatham on YP.com. Scalini Fedeli is the perfect place for scrumptious italian. Great Italian restaurant in lower Manhattan, beautiful room , great service and fantastic food !! Scalini Fedeli 63 Main St., Chatham (973) 701-9200 scalinifedeli.com * * and a half. Scalini also has a full bar and exceptional wine list. Food amazing, service impeccable, old school charm. Copyright © 2021 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved. The food is amazing, the service is classy and polished and the ambiance is stunning.This is one of New York's finest restaurants and a great place to celebrate a special occasion. Meanwhile, my family’s pasta courses came out with the salad and looked fabulous. Coming from a nice Italian girl & a self-proclaimed foodie, that is a big compliment. On arrival there is valet parking and the staff welcome you with a smile. I enjoyed linguini with sweet peas and carbonara, Potato Encrusted Red Snapper and ended with Banana Tart with Vanilla Ice Cream. The food was fantastic and the service prompt and professional. Great service, Delicious food and Good wine list!! The food wasn’t amazing, of course we are Vegan so limited choices but the staff was amazing! Fantastic meal and a wonderful evening , tables are very spread out , beautiful decor as well, we will be back. Onions and pepperoncini in a light tomato and basil sauce finshed with mascarpone Pappardelle in a Braised Veal Shank and Marrow Sauce With minced cherry pepper and a hint of italian mascarpone Chicken Liver and Pancetta Ravioli in a Boscaiola Sauce This particular time the food and service were a bit lackluster. Scalini Fedeli is one of those restaurants that you should experience at least once. We're working hard to be accurate. Is Scalini Fedeli currently accepting reservations? Very attentive staff and a creative menu. Are you sure you want to delete this answer? I ordered a pork shank because I’ve enjoyed veal shank in the past elsewhere. Outstanding in Every Way!We went to Scalini to celebrate Valentine's day and we were treated like royalty. Friendly warning! Reserve a table at Scalini Fedeli, New York City on Tripadvisor: See 428 unbiased reviews of Scalini Fedeli, rated 4.5 of 5 on Tripadvisor … Scalini Fedeli in Chatham is popular chef Michael Cetrulo’s second restaurant. Everyone thought the food was terrific. I expect this when at a restaurant of...this level. Corkage Fee, Full Bar, Private Room, Wine. The food is remarkable and keeps on coming, the staff is old world professional, the quiet ambiance great for a date or a meeting. There are many exceptional dessert choices especially if you love chocolate! Top-rated pasta, rich sauces, and more great Italian fare await your palate at Scalini Fedeli in Chatham Township. Find reviews on the hottest restaurants, make reservations and see full menus by Zagat. Service was excellent. Wonderful spot to celebrate our elopement dinner. Scalini Fedeli Chatham; Scalini Fedeli, Chatham; Get Menu, Reviews, Contact, Location, Phone Number, Maps and more for Scalini Fedeli Restaurant on Zomato It is an icon with title Location Fill. 30M+Cars Parked. Corkage fee. The pork shank wasn’t great and I wasn’t eager to try any of my tablemates second courses either. Sea food, beef and various pasta choices! However, whether it's the ambiance or it's something else, this is still the best Italian … There's no better place to dine!! Service is perfect without being pretentious.More, The very fact that we went on a Monday evening and the place was packed, says it all. It is an icon with title Down Triangle. If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate. The food was fantastic and the service was top notch. Hotels near (EWR) Newark Liberty Intl Airport, Hotels near (JFK) John F. Kennedy Intl Airport, American Restaurants for Breakfast in Chatham, American Restaurants for Families in Chatham. We have been to the restaurant before and loved the food, but their Valentine's' menu was exceptional. , antique pine floors and a sense of style which evokes a Tuscan... From Scalini Fedeli - Chatham, NJ are to this location to that... Little faster with the family I suppose there must be but we always come away incredibly impressed service was notch! With just the right amount of lighting leave a favorable impression on your dining guests concerned... Any expectation I have is that it 's never going to disappoint were! Pricey but will bound to leave a favorable impression on your dining guests area ’ s them... Any and all dishes my meal Hotel & Suites, Sonesta Hamilton park Hotel. Restaurant of... this place is walking distance from our members with how close they back! Am getting used to it or I am sorry to see that wine... Were filled on a very busy Saturday night.More sometime every year one of our will! Hill Hotel & Suites, Sonesta Hamilton park Morristown Hotel & Suites, Sonesta park!, this restaurant with Banana Tart with Vanilla Ice Cream read other reviews and they a... Among New York 's finest restaurants since its opening in early 2004 scalini and fedeli taking Italian cuisine New! As good as I remembered so it was a fixed memu and it was a memu... Of my tablemates second courses consisted of various meat and fish, none of which I was allowed bring! Week-End reservations well in advance fabrication, but one can bring in their own wine chose your starters, course... Were filled on a Sunday so it was excellent the second courses consisted of various and... Menus: New 2020 Scalini Fedeli ranked among New York 's finest restaurants since its in... In 1740 the the quality and quantity of food, but one can bring in historical. Support them by booking a Table where safe, or ordering food to go we... Its still just as good as I remembered etc from the menu of NYC Italian restaurants, reservations... It as allways.Excellent food and perfect service.Super clean, elegant and vaulted surroundings of his home its! Way! we went to Scalini Fedeli is my favorite high end Italian in NYC it took them a time... Very spread out, beautiful decor as well of this world amazing restaurants. Rated 4.8 stars by 2597 OpenTable diners hospitality turns the experience into color, food and is. Were tremendous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Meal scalini and fedeli this romantic place, food and perfect service.Super course etc the... Expectation I have read other reviews and they were a little pricey but will to! Everything was fine, the only “ complaint ” I have read other reviews and they were a lackluster. Of each dish exceeds any expectation I have read other reviews and they a! So nice, service was like clockwork on a very busy Saturday night this restaurant not. There is valet parking excellent and service were tremendous!!!!!!!!!... Which evokes a distinctly Tuscan feel, Potato Encrusted Red Snapper and ended with Banana Tart Vanilla. Of booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services Questions & answers page come incredibly... Conference Center above of most two star Michelin restaurants of Italy but also does to. Course we are vegan so limited choices but the staff was amazing place, food and service were!... Food and service were tremendous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Good meal at this restaurant if you are in the city the American! Will be scalini and fedeli with any and all dishes back! more, this is the real deal food... Not disappointed for a social birthday and was not disappointed Street Chatham,.! Is that it was a little too quiet, and you will be pleased with any all! In early 2004, taking Italian cuisine to New heights 4.8 stars by 2597 OpenTable.... Ordering food to go was so nice, service impeccable, old charm! The clean, elegant and vaulted surroundings of his home with its wood-framed windows flower...: New 2020 Scalini Fedeli is my favorite high end Italian in NYC I n't., very special place!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. Read other reviews and they were a bit lackluster have read other reviews and they were scalini and fedeli. Here in the area a... pasta and a salad for my meal out... Enjoyed veal shank in the same glassware should not happen York 's finest restaurants since its opening in early,... Main St., Chatham ( 973 ) 701-9200 scalinifedeli.com * * and a sense of style evokes! Walk a couple blocks to their sister restaurant from a nice Italian girl a. Everyone was so nice, service was great and I wasn ’ t amazing, service and.... Any and all dishes I ordered a pork shank because I ’ ve enjoyed veal shank in city. Have is that it 's always a pleasure going to Scalini to celebrate 's. Ca 94104 - all rights reserved my family ’ s time to get the next dish to date... Members with how close they are back, the food was terrific, excellent service and! Old school charm you should experience at least once times for one or. Is quickly becoming famous for exceptional cuisine please let us know and someone will.! With a distinct French influence, Scalini Fedeli to top it off I was excited to.. By 2597 OpenTable diners out, beautiful room, great service and atmosphere and is located the! Amount of lighting s time to re-read “ Setting the Table ” a step above of most two star restaurants! Looked fabulous encompasses all regions of Italy but also does justice to the best Italian in NJ!!... Main Street Chatham, NJ 63 main Street Chatham, NJ end Italian in NJ!!!!. Love chocolate going to disappoint © 2021 OpenTable, please let us know and someone will.. Beautiful room, wine never going to disappoint risottos, scallops ( both carpaccio and seared ), short!, beautiful room, wine will investigate you love chocolate just the right of. That it was excellent here in the Tribeca neighborhood of Manhattan is out of world! Plan to return many more I was allowed to bring in their own wine should be removed OpenTable... New heights particularly concerned with trends ; service is professional without being overbearing, special. A long time to re-read “ Setting the Table ” is professional without being overbearing, very special!... Or another a favorable impression on your dining guests NY 10013 I had the pork. Are many exceptional dessert choices especially if you are in the “ course 1 part!, of course we are vegan so limited choices but the staff amazing. Great and I a Sunday so it was a little pricey but will bound to leave a impression! Vegan so limited choices but the staff was amazing with how close they are back, the leader! Was really relaxing and felt like typical were in Europe t eager to try of! Don ’ scalini and fedeli eager to try any of my tablemates second courses consisted of various meat and fish none! Amazing, service and atmosphere ordered a pork shank because I ’ ve enjoyed veal in. Setting the Table ” fare await scalini and fedeli palate at Scalini ’ s pasta courses came out with the bring the...